Navigating the Costs of Sustainability in Supply Chains 
Written by Aidan Ainslie

In the Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) industry, sustainability has transitioned from a buzzword to a fundamental consumer expectation. As the demand for sustainably sourced products escalates, so does the consumers’ readiness to absorb the premium costs associated with sustainability. However, this shift prompts a critical question for the supply chain sector: How can these additional costs of sustainability be effectively integrated and justified?

While many manufacturers and retailers in the supply chain vocally champion their sustainability and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives, a significant gap between ambitious claims and concrete action persists. A study scrutinizing 25 leading CPG companies revealed a concerning trend: several organizations are allegedly manipulating accounting practices to project inflated environmental achievements or conveniently omitting substantial segments of their operations from sustainability assessments.

Despite the prevalence of such tactics, the consumer willingness to support sustainably marketed products remains robust. A McKinsey study from February 2023 underscores this trend, indicating that products with ESG-related claims witnessed a 28 percent cumulative growth over a five-year span, outpacing products devoid of such claims.

Funding sustainability in the supply chain is a multifaceted endeavor. For some, meeting sustainability benchmarks is becoming an essential criterion for market entry, inevitably leading to increased operational costs. For others, the solution lies in transferring these additional expenses downstream to the consumer. Certain demographics, particularly those raising young families, exhibit a marked preference for products perceived as sustainable. Elevating retail prices facilitates this by enabling companies to incentivize farmers to adopt and maintain practices that contribute to reducing carbon footprints.

Yet, the narrative doesn’t end here. The journey to offset the heightened costs of sustainability within supply chains necessitates innovative financial restructuring.

One such model is “green financing,” which channels investments into environmentally and socially responsible projects, products, and policies. A prominent facet of green financing is the issuance of green bonds. These instruments, earmarked exclusively for climate and environmental initiatives, offer attractive terms to sustainability-centric projects.

However, the efficacy of green bonds hinges on investor confidence in the funded projects. Historically, these funds have predominantly supported energy and public transportation infrastructure enhancements. In a supply chain context, green bonds could potentially underwrite initiatives like sustainable packaging or responsible sourcing of raw materials. The critical challenge lies in ensuring the judicious allocation of these funds within private CPG firms striving for genuine sustainability across their operations, from packaging and shipping to sourcing.

Investor interest in green bonds has surged dramatically over the past decade. In the first half of 2023 alone, green bond issuance reached a record $310 billion, accounting for 59% of the market. This surge is fueled by an increasing consumer valuation of sustainability. However, the challenge remains: ensuring that the capital raised genuinely contributes to tangible sustainability initiatives rather than being funneled into superficial marketing campaigns.

Another strategy involves engaging consumers directly through incentives. Loyalty programs rewarding eco-conscious purchasing behaviors and special offers for customers participating in sustainable initiatives can indirectly subsidize the sustainability premium. However, this approach is not devoid of challenges. For such initiatives to succeed, the incentives must be compelling enough to overcome any consumer inconvenience, fostering genuine loyalty and continued patronage of sustainable products.

In essence, managing the costs of sustainability in supply chains is a complex challenge requiring creative, collaborative solutions. Direct price adjustments to fund sustainable practices are one piece of the puzzle, but exploring alternative financing models, generating new value streams, and proactively engaging consumers are equally vital components. A truly sustainable supply chain will likely emerge from a synergistic blend of these strategies, all aligned towards a common objective of environmental stewardship and social responsibility.

Connect with the Sustainability experts at Ever.Ag to find out how you can be part of the sustainable ingredient revolution